Shadow Hearts: I, The Dreamer's Potent Debut EP Delivers Post-Hardcore Punch
519MAGAZINE.COM

Shadow Hearts: I, The Dreamer's Potent Debut EP Delivers Post-Hardcore Punch

Sounding at times a bit like a post-hardcore Linkin Park and at other times as clean as Evanescence, I, The Dreamer is a unique-sounding band with a powerful presentation. Their debut EP, *Shadow Hearts*, on Standby Records, was released on September 1 and contains five stellar tracks to introduce the band to the world.

Surprisingly, the EP doesn’t contain their previously released singles "Old Souls" or "Battle Scars," but believe it or not, that’s a great thing. While "Battle Scars" and "Old Souls" showed a band in progress, *Shadow Hearts* shows a much more completed picture – the production is superior, the songs are a little harder and at the same time a little catchier, giving a much more fun EP to listen to.

The opening track, "Rise," is a powerful punk rocker with a good mix of hardcore and pop, featuring great vocals by dueling vocalists Matt Kincaid and Alex Kincaid. "Echoes" sounds like a great single and should generate some radio play on harder stations. "Fearless" is a bit slower but flows well with the EP and would be a great live song. "The Black and White of Sleepless Nights" would have been a better track with a little less of the screeching vocals because it’s the slowest of the five tracks, whereas "Dangerous Thing" benefits from the shouting vocals much more than the slick vocals. "Dangerous Thing" features the best drumming on the EP with some killer double bass from Toby Kincaid.

The band is solid and worth checking out. Hopefully, these Birmingham, Alabama rockers will make it out to North America someday and share their live show. There’s enough of a mix of melody and hardcore to make fans of Linkin Park and Korn look to the future of the post-hardcore/nu-metal genres.

Get Tickets

Extreme at RBC Amphitheatre
JUL 22
Ticketmaster
Extreme at RBC Amphitheatre
rbc-amphitheatre · Jul 22, 2026 · 10:30 PM
More Info & Tickets
Cody Jinks at RBC Amphitheatre
AUG 2
Ticketmaster
Cody Jinks at RBC Amphitheatre
rbc-amphitheatre · Aug 2, 2026 · 10:45 PM
More Info & Tickets
Iron Maiden at Scotiabank Arena
AUG 29
Ticketmaster
Iron Maiden at Scotiabank Arena
scotiabank-arena · Aug 29, 2026 · 11:15 PM
More Info & Tickets
Iron Maiden at Scotiabank Arena
AUG 30
Ticketmaster
Iron Maiden at Scotiabank Arena
scotiabank-arena · Aug 30, 2026 · 11:15 PM
More Info & Tickets
BABYMETAL at RBC Amphitheatre
SEP 7
Ticketmaster
BABYMETAL at RBC Amphitheatre
rbc-amphitheatre · Sep 7, 2026 · 11:20 PM
More Info & Tickets
Erra at London Music Hall
SEP 21
Ticketmaster
Erra at London Music Hall
london-music-hall · Sep 21, 2026 · 10:30 PM
More Info & Tickets
Diamond Dixie at Fallsview Casino Resort
OCT 9
Ticketmaster
Diamond Dixie at Fallsview Casino Resort
Fallsview Casino · Oct 9, 2026 · 12:00 AM
More Info & Tickets
TWISTED SISTER Featuring Sebastian Bach on Lead Vocals
OCT 11
Ticketmaster
TWISTED SISTER Featuring Sebastian Bach on Lead Vocals
caesars-windsor · Oct 11, 2026 · 12:00 AM
More Info & Tickets
Editor's Note
This review was originally published shortly after the release of Shadow Hearts in September 2017. It's important to note that Linkin Park vocalist Chester Bennington, mentioned as a comparative artist, tragically passed away in July 2017, just prior to this EP's release. His legacy continues to influence the genres discussed.

Share 𝕏 f in

About Dan Savoie

From coast-to-coast newsrooms to the gritty pages of Rolling Stone and Metal Hammer, Dan doesn’t just cover the scene—he’s embedded in it. He’s traded stories with a "who’s who" of rock royalty, locking horns with legends from KISS to Metallica. Whether he’s dissecting a riff or landing a world-class exclusive, Dan delivers the raw, high-decibel truth of the industry. Living the dream? Maybe. Documenting the legends? Every damn day.

Keep scrolling for more stories